Study Finds Phoenix Business Deals Raise Failure and Debt Risk

Insolvent companies relaunched under their previous management through so-called pre-pack administrations are significantly more likely to collapse a second time and tend to return far less money to creditors, according to research conducted for the Guardian.

The findings add to a growing body of scrutiny surrounding "phoenixism," a contested insolvency practice in which a company is liquidated and its assets are reacquired by former directors, who re-emerge running a new entity stripped of prior debts. Critics argue the process can disadvantage suppliers, lenders, and other creditors left holding unpaid claims.

Read more Onsemi in Talks to Acquire Chip Startup Ferric for $1 Billion →

Pre-pack deals have long been defended by practitioners as a pragmatic tool for preserving jobs and business operations that might otherwise disappear entirely in a conventional liquidation. Supporters contend that experienced management teams are often the best equipped to revive struggling enterprises. But the new research challenges that rationale by indicating the second-chance ventures frequently end in renewed failure.

The study does not identify a definitive cause for the elevated failure rate, but its findings raise pointed questions about whether the practice adequately protects those owed money by the original collapsed business. Creditor recoveries in pre-packs involving former management were notably lower than in comparable restructurings, the research found.

Regulators and policymakers in the United Kingdom have periodically tightened oversight of pre-pack transactions, including requirements for independent scrutiny of asset valuations, yet concerns about transparency and fairness have persisted. This latest evidence is expected to renew calls for further reform of the pre-pack regime. Continue reading at Business | The Guardian.